Sep 10, 2006

The Truth About Religion?

Dhukka. That is the one word Buddha used to describe this life. A continuum of misery and "dislocation". Pessimistic as it may sound, but one can't help but take this concept for a fact at times of hardships, obviously happening in a lifetime more frequently than never.
Accepting such facts takes one to the next step, which is the attempt to survive this bumpy ride we call life. People seek guidance through the path. People grow restless in their persisting need for instructions as to how to pass successfully. Pass to where one may ask? or to what? This is when religions jump to answer this and other similar questions.

Religion /[ri-lij-uh n]/: An organized attempt to institiotionalize spirituality for mass consumption.

To a religious ear, such a definition can't be more biased; offensive even. However, just the effect of the word "attempt" is enough to strike a sensitive chord in a cynical mindset. Of course, many definitions exist for what religions are, but I found this much intriguing. No one can deny how badly the concepts of religions are abused nowadays. It isn't easy, if not impossible, to name a single war occurring during the last millennium that has nothing to do with religions. Crusades, civil and ethnic wars, india, afghanistan, wars on terrorism, israel, and even the World Wars just to name a few. Everyone knows, for example, how WWI began when the young catholic Austrio-Hungarian prince went showing off in the ultra eastern-orthodox streets of serajevo. He was shot dead with his wife because he was rich, and oh-no, he was catholic. And everytime the same thing happens; Hell breaks loose.

I realize this subject is worn out of discussion and debate over and over. But it always drives me to question my stance on religious beliefs whenever similar things happen. The ignorance of these people is beyond comprehension.
"Die Religion ist das Opium des volkes" in the famed words of Marx, is another definition. It's true that it comes from a wholly different background, considering the slacking of people -at his time- in improving their living standards on hope of divine intervention, but they share a common thing with people who fight over religious causes as we see in our days everywhere around us. That is, Ignorance.
All this is, naturally, not what religions were meant for. It's a fact that big chunks of religions are man-made. Yes even those so-called monotheistic religions. I don't see why the need to propose a new-and-improved religion every other millenium if it was possible to suggest one good-for-all-times version from the beginning. That's why it's less confusing to think of religious practices as man-made and perhaps question the validity of those which don't make a whole lot of sense. All what religions are meant to teach, after all, is making a better person out of each one of us. The ideal ethics.

"So, why not being an ethical person without the constraints of what most likely is a man-made set of rules, i.e. religions?"
A question that definitely found its way to a lot of questioning minds. One can't blame such questioning for it reflects from the atrocities being made in religions' name. But an insightful answer to this question is another question: "Why be ethical?" lol, as much as I hate answering a question with another question, yet I couldn't find a better answer. So really, if under religions we are encouraged -if not forced- to do the good and avoid the bad in order to reach an ultimate goal of entering an after-worldly nice place called "heaven", and avoid the wrath of "hells", then what are the motivation for non-religious people to act ethically? Human nature? I don't think so. Simply what human nature is all about is greed, lust, and the rest of the 7 sins that were mentioned elaborately in the Torah i think. One doesn't need the Torah even to realize how these tendencies are deep within our existence; that's just the way it is.

In addition, religions play a vital role in making a better society. Zakat in Islam stands as a practical manifestation of humanitarian empathy, for example. Sweet. So where does it all go wrong? I imagine people getting too deep in contemplating the improvements that religions had made to their lives, leading to deeper adherence to the practices which we, for the sake of this argument, described as man-made. At a certain point these people will want to invite more people to share their values, perhaps as a way of showing gratitude to what this religion make to improve their lives. And a natural evolution to this "innocent desire to bring in more people" is to first "force in" these people, then to "force out" their beliefs, to finally "force those people along with their infidellic beliefs out of our very world" hence what we have now.

Alors apparently it's a people's thing to ruin everything, and the divine (the E in E=mc^2 in one theory) has yet to have a say in what's been happening for too long by now. Too long for a human point of understanding perhaps, but nonetheless, too long.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

There is religion, and then there is what people do with said religion. This applies to Christianity, which, at one point was whole and complete. Now, however, you'd be hard pressed to find yourself in a room full of Christians where every single one of them adhered to or owned the same version of the Bible.

Similarly, you could also apply this view to Islam. This isn't to say that, like Christianity, Islam is not whole and complete anymore. On the contrary! For that is one of its miracles. Rather, in our case we have people who, instead of simply leaving things as is, have chosen to "add" or distort the original message.

Of course, one need not look further than the original source itself in order to differentiate between truth from falsehood.

Hmm. It seems I may have strayed from the original topic at hand (sorry), so allow me to get back on point. From what I understand, you claim that religions are man-made, and that is not so, at least not with the three religions of the book. What IS man-made is what the people have done to change the original texts over the years.

Think about it this way: why would God put forth multiple versions of ONE religion, i.e. Christianity? What need would He have of doing such a thing?

Because the people have moved away from the original message, God sent forth a "new" religion to correct their errors and to make certain His Truth -- Islam. Its most central idea is that God is One. This is why there is a need to "propose a new-and-improved religion every other millenium."

Furthermore, we as human beings most certainly are capable of recognizing our evil ways on our own, for we have been blessed with a mind and free will. However, we do not always choose to recognize our errors for what they are -- errors.

Think back to the days of ignorance, where the actions of the people that seemed perfectly normal and commonplace back then and were justified, now seem utterly shocking and revolting to us. Think of how they used to bury their daughters.

We have been given religion to correct all that, and to show us right from wrong.

iDip said...

Nice analysis UzF.

I liked the usage of an example from Buddhism in the beginning, why? Because the vast majority of monotheistic religions followers start thinking about “Religion” from their point of view, that is: what they think religion is/should be.

The first step to think about Religion is to think universally.

I think that religion is a mental & physical order (as in sect or cult) that defines the human’s spirituality, daily life and observation of the universe.

And yes, Religions do institutionalize, but each to its own. Here comes the role of logic, relativity and distinction between good & bad. Which billions throughout history misused, or maybe… they were misused by it!

This may sound too general, unless we think out of our “Religion Boxes” and consider the possibility of the inclusiveness of Salvation among all creatures.


P.S.
Where the HEAVEN have you been? missed your posts :)

Anonymous said...

Well, well, well, someone had disappeared like Buddha in the fields and came back enlightened, I’ll be damned.
If we assume that religions are man-mad, then ethics are also man made. In that respect evil and good are a propensity in man; Evil is not always bad since man needs some evilness for survival, and good is not always preferred for the same reasons. But if we believe in science of evolution, then social evolution of man should slowly reduce his evilness and increase his goodness, also for survival purposes. i.e.; create a balance. And accordingly; religions should be altered by man to meet the civilized demands. It would not matter then which ethnical group one follows since the goal at the end of the tunnel is one. If religions are not man made then as you mentioned one religion from the beginning of time should have been sufficient for humanity, why the divergence if they all call for the same thing; that is institutionalization? That wouldn’t make sense would it?
Wyyyyyy a7ibik, my little philosopher with big brains :*

UzF said...

Dear Extreme Moderate
I appreciate your coherent and logical reasoning. When I questioned the need for proposing new religions I was referring to implementing new "legistlations" each time; like for example the very different nature of praying in christianity, judaism, and islam. There wouldn't be a need for a whole new (or even partly new) set of rules to govern the spiritual and practical aspects of people's lives if this set was made to be perfect for human "consumption" in all times -- which is a claim by islamic doctrine, and for this matter by any other ideology by its mere existing. For the 3 major monotheistic religions, one would expect less diversity had they been really from the same source (which is not something i'm claiming false here).
Kind of running in a circle, no? :)
Anyway thank you for your point of view.

Dear iDip
I have been -and still am- all too busy with college work and other things in my life -and probably will continue be so lol-. Thanks for asking and your concern man :)
You are very balanced in your views to these subjects and I assume you've been around where I am now.. Anyway this post was merely a spur of its moment, and i am by no means a seeker of 'an' ultimate truth.
Wanna play kout? :oP

UzF said...

Dear Ayya
Ana b3d A7ibich! :)
When I read your comment in my mail a while back, I happened to just had finished studying Taoism (as a part of a class i take), so i'll share this story from Taoist tradition with you:

"A farmer's horse ran away. His neighbor commiserated, only to be told, "Who knows what's good or bad?". It was true, for the next day the horse returned, bringing with it a drove of wild horses it had befriended. The neighbor reappeared, this time with congratulations for the windfall. He received the same response" "Who knows what is good or bad?" Again this proved true, for the next day the farmer's son tried to mount one of the wild horses and fell, breaking his leg. More commiserations from the neighbor, which elicited the question" "Who knows what is good or bad?" And for a fourth time ther farmer's point prevailed, for the following day soldiers came by commandeering for the army, and the son was exempted because of his injury."

This story emphasizes the dots of opposite color found in the center of each of the over-lapping halves of the yin-yang symbol. Also later I remembered that the story of al-khidr and prophet Moses (link) from islamic tradition to be very relevant to your point.
And finally, yes, if followers of all religions agreed to follow different paths for the same goal then we would be in much less trouble!

Anonymous said...

Uzf
Religion is part of human social evolution, whether is man-made or not, it remains to have its impact upon civilization. Today humans do not need religion to indoctrinate their lives, man-made civil laws are in progress, not to say that they are perfect, but, nevertheless on the path to that perfection, it needs its own time and experience.
EM
You said that interpretation of religion is man-made. And that’s why God had sent other messengers to redirect the masses. If this argument is correct, then you are defying one of the most elementary facts in all monolithic religion; God is omniscient. i’e; ya3lam agaib, if God knew beforehand that people will divert form the original, why didn’t He make sure from the beginning that his robots (human) are insusceptible to change? And how come there is no new prophet now to redirect the course when even Moslems themselves (considering Islam the last religion that will suffice to resurrection day) are diverted from the original verse. Religion is a totalitarian belief, if you take only what suits you, then you are only contradicting yourself when you say that the holy book is the word of God that should be taken without questioning.